Last modified: 2003-07-05 by joe mcmillan
Keywords: brazil | lozenge | star (white) | sphere | states |
Links: FOTW homepage |
search |
disclaimer and copyright |
write us |
mirrors
See also :
A friend from Brazil, Carlos Noronha, transmitted me various information,
among others a color photocopy of what seems be the page of an encyclopedia,
on which figures a provisional flag of the Brazilian Republic. The flag is
almost identical to that of State of Piauí, apart from the number of stars,
21, probably referring to the number of provinces at the time. The thirteen bars in the
flag of Piauí symbolize the Brazilian country.
Jaume Ollé, 19 August 1996
I would say this was neither a provisional flag nor a revolutionary flag,
as this was the official flag of the Provisional Government of Brazil,
adopted on 15 November 1889 and abolished on 19 November 1889. The canton was
square. It was proposed with the words "Let us adopt a flag like the United States
has"--thus the 13 stripes and the stars equal to the number of Brazilian states.
As the designer of the flag "had no heraldic knowledge and no knowledge
of Brazilian tradition," the flag was rejected four days later. Possibly
it never was used (?). The ratio of the flag was possibly 5:7, as it is shown in
Ribeiro's book as 6:8 and the follow up
is drawn in 56:78 which is almost exactly 5:7.
Ralf Stelter, 8 February 2001
Brazilians seem to be even more nostalgic than Americans
about old flag designs. Several old flag designs, either of Brazil
or of this or that revolt or revolution, have made their way into
state flags. The 1889 flag seems to be the inspiration for
the flags of Goiás, Piauí,
and Sergipe.
Ole Andersen, 8 February 2001
The flag with a blue rectangle containing 20 stars for the 20 states plus one for
the Neutral Municipality
[federal district in Rio de Janeiro]was flown aboard the Brazilian naval ship
Alagoas when it
departed with Dom Pedro II and the imperial family for exile, on 16 November 1889.
This flag was the first Brazilian republican flag recognized in Europe and is
now in the Museum of the
Republic in Rio de Janeiro.
Joseph McMillan, 12 April 2001
by Joseph McMillan based on the above image by Andy Weir
According to
this Brazilian website in Portuguese, which seems to be
pretty well researched, the first flag adopted by the provisional government
on 15 November 1889) had a square black canton with twenty stars
(five rows of four) symbolizing the 20 states of the republic. This flag was
known as the flag of the Centro Republicano Lopes Travão.
Joseph McMillan,12 April 2001
Vexilologie 62 gives different patterns for this flag: 20 white
stars on a blue canton arranged
4-2-4-4-2-4 and 5-5-5-5. The pattern 4-4-4-4-4 is not shown. I would suggest
that the black canton flag
was in use a single day if at all, but may have been the previous flag of the
republicans for many years.
With the blue canton in use only four days, a small number of flags must
have been manufactured. If this is all true, flags with a black canton must be
common and those with
a blue canton very rare.
Jaume Ollé, 13-14 April 2001
I'd say that these patterns were not established and varied freely from
flag to flag, much in the lines of what happened with US flags at the
time.
Jorge Candeias, 14 April 2001
That seems a reasonable hypothesis, but then where did the flag with the
blue canton and 20 stars come from,
as opposed to the 16 December 1889 version with blue canton and 21 stars?
Joseph McMillan, 15 April 2001
Flag with 21 stars adopted by Decree Number 4 of 19 November 1889:
(From the booklet "Os Símbolos Nacionais", published by the Presidência da República, Brasília, 1986, on the 165th year since independence and 98th since establishment of the republic) Pier Paolo Lugli, 19 January 1998, decree retranslated by Joseph McMillan, 12 April 2001
by Joseph McMillan, modified from an image by Simon Frame
According to
this Brazilian website in Portuguese, the Brazilian Navy cruiser Almirante
Barroso was in the midst of a midshipmen's
training cruise around the world when the 1889 revolution took place. It departed
Brazil on 7 October 1888. It was only on 17 December 1889,
when it arrived at Colombo (now Sri Lanka), that the captain received a telegram
from the Minister of the Navy of the Provisional Government
telling him of the advent of the Republic. The captain, Custódio José
de Mello, decided to use a flag similar to the Imperial ensign but substituting
a red star for the crown. This flag was hoisted aboard the Almirante Barroso
that day. The ship subsequently received the official flag of the
Republic upon leaving Alexandria, Egypt, for Naples, on 8 April 1890.
Joseph McMillan,12 April 2001
Flag with 22 stars adopted in June 1960, according to the UK Admiralty Flags of All Nations, 1960 correction attached to the 1955 edition.
I have a color photocopy of a 22-star flag from the UK Admiralty flag book
in 1969 which was made in the local library. The 22nd star is placed below the letters,
between M and E in the scroll. I think this star must be Alpha Hydrae.
Nozomi Kariyasu, 4 April 1998
This is now the star for Mato Grosso do Sul, so it was then intended for
Guanabara! Very interesting.
Herman De Wael
Flag with 23 stars.
Adopted by Law nr 5443 of 28 May 1968:
The 23rd star is placed between the letters O and G in the scroll.
Nozomi Kariyasu, 4 April 1998
Unlike the stars on the American flag, each particular star on the Brazilian flag represents one particular state. The following are the stars added since adoption of the basic design of the Brazilian flag in 1889, with the dates of creation of the states and territories:
date | state | nr of states |
nr of stars |
adoption of flag |
---|---|---|---|---|
1889 | 20 original states + federal district (within Rio de Janeiro) | 20 | 21 | Flag of 19 November 1889 |
1903 | regaining of Acre territory | 20 | 21 | no change |
1943 | creation of 3 new territories : Amapá, Rio Branco, Guaporé | 20 | 21 | no change |
1960 | moving of federal district from Rio de Janeiro to Brasilia creation of new State - Guanabara - out of former capital territory |
21 | 22 | Flag of June 1960 |
1962 | statehood of Acre | 22 | 23 | Flag of 28 May 1968 |
1975 | merging of states of Guanabara and Rio de Janeiro (as RdJ) | 21 | 22 | never |
1979 | creation of Mato Grosso do Sul out of Mato Grosso | 22 | 23 | no change |
1982 | statehood of Rondônia | 23 | 24 | never |
1989 | creation of Tocantins out of Goiás | 24 | 25 | never |
1991 | statehood for Amapa and Roraima | 26 | 27 | Flag of 11 May 1992 |
Herman De Wael, 20 January 1998
It turns out that the Brazilians were not very vigilant in changing their
flag to account for the creation of new states. Between 1975 and 1979, there
was even one star too many! Upon the creation of Mato Grosso do Sul, this
surplus star must have been reassigned. This may seem strange, but the article
in the Brazilian Law that states that, upon the disappearance of a state, its star
should also be removed, was apparently only added in 1992. Nevertheless, the
place and size of the 23rd star (under the EM of ORDEM) seems strangely
appropriate for Mato Grosso do Sul (a large state in the interior) and
absolutely inappropriate for Guanabara (a very small state on the coast). However,
no amount of research has been able to track down an alternate
design for a 23-star flag. Maybe even two reassignments have occurred and the star now
symbolizing Acre
(the small one under the O of prOgresso) was the one originally intended for
Guanabara.
Herman De Wael, 26 February 1998
This second (first?) reassignment did not take place. New evidence
provided by Nozimo Kariyasu reveals that there was indeed a 23-star version in
use after 1960, and the 23rd star (for Guanabara) may indeed correspond to the
one now intended to represent Mato Grosso do Sul.
Herman De Wael, 30 April 1998